Feeds
- RSS2

Pariprashnena (to inquire submissively). Questions & Answers resource for all devotees.

Welcome Guest!
Want to take part in these discussions? If you have an account, sign in now.
If you don't have an account, apply for one now.

Health: Can we mix milk with salt?

Bottom of Page

1 to 19 of 19

- CommentAuthorlalitagopi
- CommentTimeAug 8th 2007
I read that milk mixed with salt causes leprosy. How it is that we have recipe for Milli juli subji ka soup - where is milk,water, vegetables and..salt?
- CommentAuthorSaryu
- CommentTimeAug 8th 2007
And tamatar ka soup in the same book.
- CommentAuthoramalagaura
- CommentTimeAug 8th 2007
There was a quote in another thread that milk mixed with salt is unofferable.

From Prabhupada:
Letter to: Aniruddha
—
San Francisco
9 April, 1968
68-04-09

...

Milk and salt should never be mixed, it is improper, and will cause leprosy. But salt can be mixed with yogurt.
- CommentAuthorlalitagopi
- CommentTimeAug 8th 2007
Yes, I know, I read this, but in many "bona fide" Hare Krishna cook books are salty milky soups and sauces....hm hm...,interesting.....
- CommentAuthorsol
- CommentTimeAug 9th 2007
I'm not sure, but according to ayurveda usually when they say don't mix this with thas is as it is, just plain milk with salt.

maybe it is not like that when there are some other ingredients but I don't have proofs of this hehe
- CommentAuthoramalagaura
- CommentTimeAug 9th 2007
Some devotees said it becomes like meat. Prabhupada did say milk is transformed blood, so probably related to that in some esoteric way.

How about cream?

What about white sauce, that is made from milk or cream?
- CommentAuthorlalitagopi
- CommentTimeAug 10th 2007
Hmm... its depend..can be made from milk or from cream also. Cream, joghurt or curd...this is not problem.
- CommentAuthorphani
- CommentTimeAug 13th 2007
as far as i understand, this instruction (not to mix milk with salt) refers to milk itself, not to preparations that contain milk. if you add milk to some other stuff, subji, soup, in most cases the milk will become 'denaturalized,' i.e., it won't remain milk. it'll curdle or change in some other way.

i'll ask kurma prabhu from australia, the world famous hare krsna cook. he runs a blog where he answers questions. (don't have the URL at my fingertips right now; i'll provide it with his reply.)

ys phani.
Thankful People: lalitagopi
- CommentAuthorsitapati
- CommentTimeAug 13th 2007
I asked Jayapataka Swami about this letter some years ago, and he gave an interesting insight.

First, some context. Srila Prabhupada wrote that letter to Aniruddha because it had become common practice for devotees to add salt to milk that had been burned while boiling it. Adding salt to burnt milk has the effect of getting rid of the burnt taste.

Amala Gaura's hint about the blood is the angle that Jayapataka Swami took. He told me that he wasn't familiar with this particular instruction of Srila Prabhupada, but that milk is a transformation of the blood of the cow. The difference between the milk and the blood, however, is that milk is sweet, and blood is salty. So adding salt to milk makes it again like blood, as Amala Gaura points out.

It's probably not a good idea to develop a taste for blood... :-)
Thankful People: lalitagopi
- CommentAuthorabhiram
- CommentTimeAug 14th 2007
> It's probably not a good idea to develop a taste for blood... :-)
Maybe the same could be said about soya beans because they taste like meat...
- CommentAuthorSaryu
- CommentTimeAug 15th 2007
>Maybe the same could be said about soya beans because they taste like meat...

You're probably referring to all those "vegetarian steaks" and "vegetarian pork" or whatever. I don't know what they taste like, as the analogy is disgusting enough for me to avoid such products, but if they taste anything like tofu then the only "meaty" thing in them would be their name, look and probably texture.
- CommentAuthorabrennan
- CommentTimeAug 25th 2007
In the Pancaratra Pradipa it says milk with salt alone is not to be offered

mixed in other food, even with milk present, it is acceptable to Krishna
- CommentAuthorlalitagopi
- CommentTimeAug 26th 2007
hmmm...but how dou know ?:o/
- CommentAuthorabrennan
- CommentTimeAug 26th 2007
how do i know it is in the book?

I read it on page 63 under "forbidden food"

Common forbidden foods include.... ....and milk with salt in it**

in the page footer there is this

**Salty preparations like soup which include milk are allowed.

So I guess I only know as i read it : )
Thankful People: lalitagopi, Gordon
- CommentAuthora
- CommentTimeAug 27th 2007
Leprosy is caused by a specific bacteria. You can drink all the salted milk you want to, and you will never, never, never get leprosy.

Good God, please enter the 21st century. You are tainting the entire movement with your silly superstitions.
- CommentAuthormishra
- CommentTimeAug 27th 2007
a= ...and we landed the moon..
The most amazing one: if Armstrong was first to walk to the moon, then who filmed him walking down the ladder? Who is the gullible here?
- CommentAuthormishra
- CommentTimeAug 27th 2007
...and illness is not caused primarily by bacterias entering you by some bad luck. Bacterias are there by the millions, always. It is the wrong milieu of the body that permits them to thrive. So, eating the wrong things can and do trigger illnesses. But that is another question...
http://www.pariprashnena.com/discussion/259/what-are-the-real-causes-of-illness/
- CommentAuthorVEDA
- CommentTimeAug 27th 2007
Armstrong was supposedly filmed by a module-mounted TV camera. http://www.clavius.org/mesacam.html
- CommentAuthorabhiram
- CommentTimeAug 27th 2007
it was kubrick who shot it.

1 to 19 of 19

Add your comments

Back to Questions Top of Page

Username	Password

Feeds

Health: Can we mix milk with salt?